Where Do Hugo From Here?
Endless controversy surrounding its biggest annual awards has the sci-fi literary community reeling
The Hugo Awards, presented at science fiction’s yearly WorldCon convention, are the Grammys of the sci-fi world. Voted on by fans, the award represents the apex of achievement in the genre. Because we identify many of the great literary works of sci-fi (Dune, The Left hand of Darkness, Neuromancer, etc.) as titular “Hugo winners,” a win places an author in the front rank of science fiction royalty.
With so much at stake, a certain amount of skullduggery is inevitable. Over the past decade or so, the Hugos have become a battleground for competing visions of sci-fi, literature and even culture itself. The 2015 awards got attention for a slate of nominations that conservative writers Brad Torgerson, Larry Correia and Vox Day pressed as a protest against what they saw as a diminishment of the institution from a badge of excellence to “an affirmative action award.” Their efforts led to backlashes both online and in the award process itself that left the Hugos terminally politicized.
That is not to say that science fiction has always been necessarily apolitical. While one could argue that evoking visions of the future is an inherently political act, it was really with the “New Wave” of sci-fi writers in the sixties and seventies that the genre solidified into its present form as a necessarily humanist, progressive enterprise. Pushing for improvement of the human condition, the Earth’s environment and race relations seemed a natural extension of the genre’s imaginative aspirations.
Seizing and protecting science fiction’s reputation as such has increasingly been the preoccupation of its creative class and the more activist elements of its fanbase. Since the 2015 Hugos, sci-fi and related genres have seen a ferment of politically motivated censorship and cancellations, some of which we have covered in this periodical. But the 2023 Hugo Awards saw the politicization of sci-fi taken to an entirely new level.
It is perhaps fitting that the site of the 2023 WorldCon was Chengdu, China. The Chinese, with their cultural penchant for overdoing everything, even constructed a brand new science fiction museum to host the event. By all reports, attendees had a wonderful time. But the Hugo hopefuls? Not so much.
The problem came three months after the event, when Dave McCarty, that year’s overseer of the Hugo Awards process, made public the stats of the Hugo ballot process. What immediately became clear to interested observers was that the committee had arbitrarily excluded a number of works with sufficient votes to appear on the final ballot. Among these were works by sci-fi stalwart Neil Gaiman and that year’s Nebula Award winning novel, Babel It quickly became apparent that some agenda was at work.
Extensive post–mortems of the Hugo process and its result are ongoing. The controversy has even been sufficiently interesting to merit the attention of Esquire Magazine. In addition to the Hugo exclusions, the unexplained absence of a number of Chinese nominees as well as the presence of a 2015-style “slate” of are under examination. But the initial take-aways are sufficiently interesting to merit comment.
The initial conclusion among many was that the Chinese government–no friend to free expression–somehow pressured the Hugo committee into advancing some nominees while excluding others. But more recent analysis suggests that McCarty and his fellow Hugo award organizers engaged in an act of self-censorship to avoid offending their Chinese hosts.
According to Abigail Nussbaum in her blog, Asking the Wrong Questions, “in 2023, Hugo administrator Dave McCarty added another criteria to the validation process, that of compliance with Chinese political and social agendas. The emails, leaked by team member Diane Lacey, show the validation team compiling dossiers on both nominated works and their authors.” The results of the dossiers led to a confidential spreadsheet (since leaked) showing “the list of nominees in each category, with a column designating each as ‘no issues’, ‘possible issues’, etc.” So much for imaginative aspirations!
Bloggers and authors–particularly those who might one day be up for a Hugo themselves–are feverishly deconstructing all of this and asking how we can avoid such a situation in the future. A spate of resignations from both WorldCon and the Hugos, recommendations on changing the voting process or membership vetting process are all intended to address the problem from an organizational and procedural standpoint. But the problem may be more cultural than organizational.
Since 2015, the science fiction community has become increasingly strident in its enforcement of “cancelable” offenses. Authors, actors or film makers who transgress the ever-shifting boundaries of “permissible” discourse have found themselves on the receiving end of onslaughts from angry mobs. Projects have been canceled, actors fired and publishing contracts pulled on the strength of these supposedly grassroots efforts, which are often justified from the height of some supposed moral high ground. But one would do well to consider the broader geography.
Once freed from the bottle, the genie of censorship and cancellation is impossible to replace, and its trajectory impossible to predict. It is perhaps fitting that this controversy comes on the heels of a WorldCon held in the most repressive, totalitarian country on Earth. In embracing cancel culture and convening in China, WorldCon and the Hugo committee chose to lay down with the devil. The same community that bayed for the blood of Gina Carano and got her sacked from Star Wars seems aghast that cancellation has infiltrated the citadel of their Hugo holy-of-holies. Beyond addressing organizational and procedural foibles, the sci-fi community would do well to look in the mirror and recognize the monster staring back at them.



