Nate Bargatze and Taylor Tomlinson Ascend
A return to normal comedy
Fans of standup may not be surprised, but the general public is suddenly dealing with two new faces at the top of the comedy ladder. Nate Bargatze hosted Saturday Night Live last weekend to a great reception, and this week, Stephen Colbert named Taylor Tomlinson the host of the new ‘After Midnight’ show on CBS, which will follow his show. Who are these people? Where did they come from? Those answers are simple, but more important is what the comics represent. Bargatze and Tomlinson, above all else, are normal, and after years where comedy has teetered between the poles of pretentious woke preaching and studied edgelord anarchism, audiences are ready for a laid-back slice of life. These comics provide a chill relief from the exhausting standup wars.
Clearly, the algorithm has been preparing me for their arrival. Tomlinson made it big among the kids on TikTok, but I have been watching her schtick, and Bargatze’s, on Facebook reels, where their captioned jokes appear regularly alongside old Mitch Hedberg routines and Bill Burr appearances on Conan. Bargatze nudged through the door first, and let me tell you, the man is a delight. You’d have to be dead inside to not enjoy Nate Bargatze.
Bargatze has universal appeal. He lives in Nashville and grew up in small-town Tennessee, so even though he cut his teeth in the New York comedy scene, his routines have a kind of homespun observational vibe about them, like if Jerry Seinfeld moved to Franklin County. He jokes about county fairs and going out on the lake on his sister’s boat, but he’s not a “get er done” cornpone comic like the Blue Collar Comedy Tour millionaires.
He’s a distressed househusband who doesn’t use tools, likes to sleep late, and finds modern life vaguely befuddling. But he’s no egghead, either; he went to community college for one semester, and it shows. On his Saturday Night Live monologue, he complained about books having “so many words.” This is about as regular-guy as comedy gets. No one on any notch on the political spectrum was complaining about his SNL appearance. There is nothing to offend.
Tomlinson, on the other hand, is more of a regular girl. She may seem hipper than Bargatze, but that’s only because he’s a dad in his mid-40s and she’s a single gal in her early 30s. But she’s also relatable to both blue and red America. Tomlinson grew up in Orange County, otherwise known as the Republican Los Angeles, and a lot of her best material deals with her ridiculous evangelical Christian background. Her material is vaguely edgy, but that’s only because she has a brash, loud personality. She is neurotic and admittedly bipolar, so she doesn’t quite go sexual scorched-Earth like Iliza Schlesinger and Nikki Glazer. As she puts it in one of her best and most honest routines, she’s “subjectively hot.”
She’s an excellent choice to be a rare female late-night host. Her politics lean toward the liberal, but she’s not didactic like Samatha Bee or Michelle Wolf. If she expresses politics at all, it’s just because she’s a rich, strong, attractive young woman who knows what she wants out of life and has clearly achieved it. But that’s a type that both the right and the left can manifest.
Edgy libertarian comics like Tim Dillon command huge audiences, both onstage and on their podcasts. I suppose there are still 10 people out there who find Hannah Gadsby funny. People go to Dave Chappelle shows like they’re going to hear a rich motivational speaker. Laughter is sometimes an option at those shows. But Bargatze and Tomlinson are entertainers for a new kind of Middle America, PG-13 normal entertainers for PG-13 normal people. After decades of pompous shrieking that passes for comedy, they are a welcome relief, and they’re both about to be very, and deservedly, rich.



