Why I Spent the Start of Christmas With Thomas Haden Church as a Dog

There’s more holiday cheer in putting your arm into a wood chipper than watching this ‘Most-Watched’ Netflix movie

I hate dog movies. I would like that on the record before we go any further. I would have much preferred to open the Christmas season with a Hallmark film in which a wealthy city girl travels to a small town, falls for the man who works at the cookie shop and learns the true meaning of something, but the number one movie in the world on Netflix this week was A Dog’s Perfect Christmas, so I had to confront one of the great terrors of my childhood: watching dogs on television.

The film is based on the novel of the same name by W. Bruce Cameron, who also wrote A Dog’s Purpose, the movie version of which is, for me, the Titanic of films about sad dogs, not because it is any good but because it was manufactured to make you cry, and you do cry, of course you do, how could you not. This one is not good either, and I will explain why, but first you need to understand why I am not the most objective person on the subject of dogs.


A Dog’s Perfect Christmas ★ (1/5 stars)
Directed by: Cathryn Michon
Written by: W. Bruce Cameron, Cathryn Michon
Starring: Dennis Quaid, Milo Ventimiglia, Brooke Lena Johnson, Mary Steenburgen, Jennifer Tilly, Kathleen Rose Perkins, Thomas Haden Church (voice)
Running time: 101 mins


I was around five years old when I watched a Canadian series called The Littlest Hobo, about a stray German shepherd who went from town to town helping everyone he met and who, whenever someone tried to reward him, even with a bone, simply disappeared. Hobo wanted no reward. Hobo only did good. Hobo made me cry, and the theme song made me cry twice as hard, and I have never owned a dog in my life, so it is safe to say that my trauma began with him and has followed me to this day. Which is why I sat down for an hour and forty minutes or so of Cameron armed with popcorn, a soda and a chocolate bar, psychologically braced, and why, before two minutes had passed, there was already a dog on screen, a long-faced basset hound with a deep, mournful voice that bore no relation to his face, telling me that he was sad and remembering the days when he had once been happy. There is no worse way to open a dog movie than a dog whose thoughts you can hear, and I had barely finished the first sip of soda.

The plot, such as it is, goes like this. Dennis Quaid plays Sander, a widower who looks either like a caveman or like the long-lost brother of The Dude from The Big Lebowski, and who badly needs a haircut, a shave and a way out of the depression he has been in since his wife died two Christmases ago. He is a grump, which is not how the dog remembers him in those opening flashbacks, where Winstead, our narrator, looks back fondly on the happy days when the wife was alive. Quaid is the father of Milo Ventimiglia, and every time I see Ventimiglia my brain delivers either Jess from Gilmore Girls or Rocky Balboa’s useless son, and the real problem is that he sometimes looks as young as his own daughter and almost like the son of his own wife. The daughter, Ello, is a teenager who likes ice skating and is naturally rebellious, because that is the easiest stereotype available for a teenager, and for reasons nobody explains they all live together: the grandfather, Jess, the wife, the daughter, the two little ones, and the dog.

Dennis Quaid as Sander and Ruby in A Dog’s Perfect Christmas. Courtesy Netflix 

Very early on you realize this family has problems. Like every family in a Christmas movie. In this case the work problem belongs to Ventimiglia. He works for a company whose actual business remains a mystery. What we do know is that he is in charge of rearranging the furniture and the layout of the workstations. He is presenting to his boss, a formidable woman whose name I never caught — I’m not even sure she gets a proper credit. She informs him that the CEO is seriously considering closing their apparently important branch. For reasons known only to her and to Jess/Rocky Jr., Ventimiglia’s grand idea is to scrap the cubicles and create open, integrated spaces. If he succeeds, the CEO might decide the company can now make more money. I know that makes no sense. Because it makes no sense.

In the middle of this meeting the boss casually mentions that her son will be starting at the same high school where Ventimiglia’s daughter happens to study. Ventimiglia immediately offers to have Ello show the boy around campus. The boss looks at him and says something along the lines of, “You would just hand her over like that?” and he says yes. I said out loud, “What the hell is this?” He is perfectly willing to make the arrangement, and Ello soon meets the boy and, of course, falls for him. It is a romantic arc that never comes within shouting distance of even the most basic Hallmark Christmas romance. Because this is another place where the film fails completely: there is a total absence of emotional empathy and even less of any real romantic angle. When the importance of the characters cooking Christmas dinner clearly outweighs a mother lying in hospital on the verge of a coma, you know you are watching something deeply strange.

Meanwhile Dennis Quaid is being pursued by three widows who apparently do not mind that he looks like a caveman. One of them, I only discovered afterwards, is Jennifer Tilly. I challenge anyone to recognize Jennifer Tilly in this movie. Another is Mary Steenburgen, who eventually lands the first kiss Quaid has allowed himself since his wife died. So we have Jess/Rocky Jr. trying to redesign the office so the CEO will not fire him, Quaid circling the idea of love again, Ello navigating a romance that involves ice skates (I genuinely thought there would be a competition or at least some Christmas skating set-piece, but nothing of the sort happens), and the dog Winstead materializing in every scene with the voice of Thomas Haden Church, which continues to irritate for the entire running time because it adds nothing and simply fractures whatever atmosphere the scene was trying to build.

Then one morning the mother, Ventimiglia’s wife, starts throwing up. The daughter asks if she is pregnant. She is not. They take her to the doctor and admit her to hospital. Apparently it is a simple infection and she is not even on antibiotics yet, according to her husband. What is truly remarkable is that neither her father-in-law, nor her daughter, nor anyone else in the family goes to visit her. We spend half the movie with this woman deteriorating in hospital until she finally slips into a coma, and only then does anyone decide it might be a good idea to show up. Apparently it is far more important that Quaid keep flirting with widows, that Ello keep skating towards love, and that the dog keep speaking in the voice of Thomas Haden Goshdarn Church. The woman is parked in a hospital bed and we will not see her again until she wakes up.

Of course the obstacles arrive. For Ventimiglia to carry out his great office-remodel vision, something happens that I will not spoil, so you can experience the pure incoherence for yourselves. Quaid must wrestle with his internal demons of grief before he can allow himself to be kissed by Claire. And Ello has no real complications in her search for love except for her comatose mother, who remains mostly unproblematically alone in the hospital.

A Dog’s Perfect Christmas. Winstead in A Dog’s Perfect Christmas. Courtesy Netflix.

And then, because this level of insanity was apparently not enough, both the author of the book and the director (who happens to be his wife) decided that what this story really needed was another dog. Enter Ruby, a small dog abandoned in a park by someone in a van. For some mysterious reason Ruby does not speak. Only Thomas Haden Church is allowed to talk, and only through Winstead. Ruby, who ranks somewhere below the comatose mother in narrative importance, simply starts bouncing around the frame. The ending is so obvious that I will not insult you by recounting it.

And so this movie, which I kept watching out of some residual faith in the “most-watched films and series” on Netflix, turns out to be a terrible way to begin the Christmas season. I do not want to sound like the Grinch. But I think I am better off clinging to my childhood memories. Hobo never spoke with the voice of Thomas Haden Church. Hobo did not need to chase things around the house. Hobo would have woken the woman from her coma. Hobo would have taught Ruby how to talk. I don’t know. At the very least, Hobo would have made me shed the first tear of this holiday season.

 You May Also Like

Dr. Carlos Flores

Dr. Carlos Flores is a journalist, geopolitical analyst, editor, film and literary critic; author of "La moda del.suicidio" (Comala, 2000), "Temporada Caníbal" (Random House, 2004), and "Unisex" (Santillana, 2008). After finally escaping the Venezuelan dictatorship, he is now a political refugee, closely following in the footsteps of Don Quixote, somewhere in La Mancha, Spain.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *