‘Elsinore’ Takes Us Into the ReDiscover’d Country

Can Andrew Scott’s masterful show make this Hamlet-adjacent film a classic?

Grappling with the haunting, daunting role of Hamlet becomes a metaphor for the majesty of life itself in the elegiac Elsinore, about a real-life West End tragedy that struck London’s theater world in the fall of 1989. The film, a noble-death drama that chooses reverence over revelation, has lousy timing, since it’s coming out less than twelve months after Chloé Zhao’s acclaimed Hamnet, which also mined the power of that play as a vehicle for cathartic mourning. Two Shakespeare-soaked cinematic mediations on mortality within the span of a year? Even Banquo’s ghost would call that overkill.

Elsinore ★★★ (3/5 stars)
Directed by: Simon Stone
Written by: Stephen Beresford
Starring: Andrew Scott, Olivia Coleman, Billie Piper, Johnny Flynn, Luke Thompson, David Dawson, Peter Mullan, Juliet Stevenson
Running time: 111 mins


Adding to his vocational despair is the quiet terror of AIDS, the devastating and terminal immunodeficiency virus that cast a paralyzing pall over gay life during that decade. Ian Charleson is a gay actor in a time when —if you wanted a movie career — you had to pretend to be straight. “They make us into liars,” says one of his closeted friends. “And then they make us ashamed of it.” Charleson sees other people with the telltale Kaposi’s sarcoma lesions that early AIDS sufferers initially developed, and diligently checks his own body for signs of them daily. Until, one day, he finds one.
Andrew Scott as Ian Charleson in Elsinore; Courtesy Focus Features

Meanwhile, at the storied National Theatre, mercurial wunderkind Daniel Day-Lewis is headlining a production of Hamlet directed by Richard Eyre (Johnny Flynn). In an infamous performance on September 5, Day-Lewis suddenly freezes onstage — and abruptly walks out. Eyre needs a new prince of Denmark, and fast. Not an easy task, since it’s the Everest of stage roles. But at the top of his list comes Charleson, who is not only a much-respected stage actor but one who Eyre knows, since Charleson played Sky Masterson in his acclaimed production of Guys and Dolls just a few years earlier.

Charleson is thrilled at the chance to play such an iconic character in such an illustrious venue. “It’s the greatest part in the greatest theatre,” he says. But he can’t lie to Eyre about his diagnosis — even though he’s chomping at the bit to be in his production. Eyre, devastated by the news, reluctantly agrees to let him be Hamlet and to keep his illness a secret. And that role of a lifetime becomes an end-of-days lifeline, as Charleson willingly, enthusiastically, obsessively, embraces the demanding job fully knowing that it will also hasten his death.
“People get years when they thought they’d only have months,” explains Dr. Margaret Johnson (Olivia Coleman), the brusque, no-nonsense physician who has bravely cared for hundreds of AIDS patients while other doctors, fearful of the disease, were too busy sanitizing their hands at the slightest sign of infection. Johnson offers innovative treatments that extend the lives of her patients and, for the same reason, strongly objects when Charleson tells her about his latest gig which will hasten his fatigue and ill-health. But what’s the point of living if you don’t have anything to live for? “It’s not just preservation,” insists Charleson. “It’s glory. It’s joy!”
Yorick and Andrew Scott as Ian Charleson in Elsinore; Courtesy Focus Features

So goes the carpe diem cri-de-coeur Elsinore, as Charleson throws himself into the mentally and physically demanding part even as it accelerates his own demise. “There’ll be no more talk of death,” scolds Dr. Johnson. “That’ll be tricky,” cracks Charleson as he memorizes yet another soliloquy from the immortal bard’s masterpiece. To be or not to be, indeed!

Elsinore is a phenomenal showcase for Scott’s abilities as a performer, capturing Charleson’s feverish commitment with an intensity that’s both wild-eyed and tender. This is a live-to-the-hilt role, a study of theater as a place of rapturous experiences worth its repeated sacrifices.
But as a story, the film doesn’t transcend its trappings as a heartfelt but narrow triumph-of-the-human-spirit portrait. We hear snippets from Hamlet, during the rehearsals and performances — both famous quotations and lesser lines — but those fragments, while reflecting Charleson’s inner turmoil, don’t really deepen or enrich it. A lot of the film’s artistic heavy lifting comes from its insistently pallid cinematography, a palette of wan colors smothered in shiny sun flares that constantly bathe Charleson in beatific light.
Despite all the bells and whistles, the spot-on period production design and the go-for-broke thespian commitments, Elsinore doesn’t elevate its material beyond the superficial, delivering an undeniably sincere tribute that makes for a fairly mundane narrative. Charleson aches to work, he gets AIDS, he gets a chance to be Hamlet, he plays Hamlet. And then he dies. The rest is silence.

 

 You May Also Like

Stephen Garrett

Stephen Garrett is the former film editor of 'Time Out New York’ and has written about the movie industry for more than 20 years. A Rotten Tomatoes certified reviewer, Garrett is also the founder of Jump Cut, a marketing company that creates trailers and posters for independent, foreign-language, and documentary films.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *