Who Watches ‘The Watchers’?
As few people as possible, we don’t want to give hope to the next generation of Shyamalans
The thing M Night Shyamalan’s daughter Ishana’s debut, The Watchers, has most in common with her father’s (brilliant) work is, unfortunately, the marketing. It engineers more tension than the film itself. Dakota Fanning and friends find themselves trapped in a mysterious glass cage in the middle of the forest, seemingly at the whim of creatures, called Watchers, who indeed love to Watch. Defy that desire and they shall be dragged down into the earth. Ooh, that looks neat. What’s going on in that picture? The answer to that will shock and fascinate few.
Where Shyamalan Sr. finds his artistic success in being defiantly cringe, Shyamalan Jr. gives in to nearly every modern horror trend, “normalizing” her father’s tics. Sure, it’s high concept, twist-centric and tense, but dad has proven time and again that real filmmaking is so much more than that; it’s soul bearing. Where father specifies character idiosyncracies to a painfully ego-dead degree, daughter finds difficulty building any character at all.
Dakota Fanning’s Mina’s Dead Mom background is much hackier than (oft) character-lacking Christopher Nolan Dead Wife meme ever was, despite it being far more necessary. No one has any quirks, subtle or otherwise. While there is a character metaphor at the center of the mystery, its grounding is entirely perfunctory. At this point in the zeitgeist a horror film About Grief/Trauma is going to have to work a lot harder than this one does to make us buy that said event deserves to linger as passable motivation.
Said character metaphor comes with a central image as well. Our captives must face a one-way mirror as the Watchers Watch them at night. One wishes this image was maybe even more centralized, as it’d as least give us a hint of abstraction, and mitigate the fact that it renders the monster reveal somewhat predictable. Still, that much would be disappointing regardless, for the trendiness extends also to its design. Without giving away too much, let’s just say there are popular cryptids that look and behave just the same, and there’s no eponymous conspiratorial Book of Enoch tie-in to justify that.
It’s fine for a film to coast on plot swerves. In the pre-‘”elevated” days, the emotive substance of a genre picture was far more backgrounded. For as contemporary as the character writing is here, the film does indeed seek plot first, which as unintelligent as it sounds is not an issue in and of itself. The problem is that none of it surprises in the slightest. The revealed system at work has too small of a scope: the nature of the forest is nothing so Byzantine as to intrigue past “it’s magical”.
It’s a huge risk to stake your art on a missed prediction by an increasingly screen-addicted audience. The best part of the picture, and indeed the only part with a REAL Shyamalan touch is the crappy reality show DVD that the “Watchers” left, with a TV, in the glass cage for the captives to view on repeat. It’s a peculiar and wonky touch in what’s otherwise indistinguishable from the non-familial Shyamalan knock-offs of the 2000s.




Lore, let alone revisionist lore, doesn’t make a movie, but it is explicitly Enochian I think — albeit Samyaza propaganda about a Nephilim escaping from Tartarus. It even includes antediluvian longing for the time where the Watchers and Nephilim roamed the earth before they were imprisoned.